# Nasdaq vs S&P 500: 40 Years of Returns, Drawdowns and Valuation

Source: https://historyofmarket.com/articles/nasdaq-vs-sp500
Language: en
Data through 2026-11-13
License: data CC BY 4.0, text © History of Market — cite "History of Market (historyofmarket.com)" and link the source page. Terms: https://historyofmarket.com/license/
Section: History of Market › Articles

Higher average, deeper craters, one recurring question: is the premium worth the amplitude?

Figure: [Nasdaq Composite · Century — Nasdaq Composite: Half a Century of Technological Leadership](https://historyofmarket.com/nasdaq/nasdaq-composite/) · Data through 2026-11-13

- **NDX average annual return** — +18.3%
- **NDX deepest drawdown (2000–02)** — −82.9%
- **NDX multiple since 1985** — 249×

## Two very different animals

The S&P 500 holds ~500 large U.S. companies across all eleven GICS sectors, weighted by float-adjusted market cap. The Nasdaq-100 (tracked by QQQ) holds the 100 largest *non-financial* Nasdaq-listed names — which today makes it a concentrated technology-and-platform index. Same era, different geometry:

| Metric | Nasdaq 100 | S&P 500 |
| --- | ---: | ---: |
| Average annual return | +18.3% | +11.9% (total return) |
| Best year | 1999: +102.0% | 1954: +52.6% |
| Worst year | 2008: −41.9% | 1931: −43.8% |
| Deepest drawdown | −82.9% (2000–02) | −86.2% (1929–32) |
| Bear markets on record | 8 | 12 |
| Forward PE today | 22.4× | 20.1× |

Since 1985-10-01, the Nasdaq 100 has multiplied **249×** (from 112 to 27,944 as of 2026-11-13).

## The price of the higher return

The Nasdaq 100's edge — +18.3% average annual return vs the S&P's +11.9% — is paid for in amplitude:

- **2000–2002: −82.9%.** The canonical bubble unwind. The S&P fell −49.1% over the same stretch. An NDX investor at the 2000 top waited ~15 years to break even; the S&P investor ~7.
- **2008: −41.9%** in a single calendar year.
- Roughly **12% of all 5-year holding windows** ended negative for the NDX (vs under 10% for the S&P) — the concentration cuts both ways.

## Which one should you own?

The honest answer is that they answer different questions. The S&P 500 is a bet on U.S. large-cap capitalism, sector-diversified. The Nasdaq 100 is a leveraged expression of one theme — technology-platform dominance — that has been the winning theme for two decades but carries single-theme risk, currently at a 22.4× forward multiple vs the S&P's 20.1×. Owning QQQ on top of an S&P index fund doubles down on the same seven mega-caps that already dominate both (see [Mag 7 concentration](https://historyofmarket.com/mag7/mag7-concentration/)).

## FAQ

### Which has higher returns, Nasdaq or S&P 500?

The Nasdaq 100 has averaged +18.3% per year since 1986 vs the S&P 500's +11.9% (total return since 1928) — but with roughly double the drawdown depth: −83% in 2000–02 vs the S&P's −49%.

### Is QQQ riskier than SPY?

Yes, structurally: ~100 names vs 500, no financials/energy/staples ballast, and top-10 weight near half the fund. About 12% of NDX 5-year windows ended negative vs under 10% for the S&P.

### What is the Nasdaq 100's forward PE today?

About 22.4× (terminal consensus, as of 2026-11-14), vs 20.1× for the S&P 500.

> Computed from https://historyofmarket.com/api/ndx/annual-returns.json, https://historyofmarket.com/api/ndx/drawdowns.json, https://historyofmarket.com/api/sp500/annual-tr.json and https://historyofmarket.com/api/ndx/forward-pe.json, refreshed each trading day.

## Further reading

- [QQQ annual returns since 1999](https://historyofmarket.com/nasdaq/nasdaq100-annual/)
- [Nasdaq 100: 59 historical drawdowns](https://historyofmarket.com/nasdaq/ndx-drawdown/)
- [Nasdaq 100 forward PE, monthly back to 2001](https://historyofmarket.com/nasdaq/ndx-forward-pe/)
- [Magnificent 7 share of the S&P 500](https://historyofmarket.com/mag7/mag7-concentration/)
- [S&P 500 average annual return, properly read](https://historyofmarket.com/articles/sp500-average-annual-return)

---

Data: https://historyofmarket.com/api/ndx/annual-returns.json · https://historyofmarket.com/api/ndx/drawdowns.json · https://historyofmarket.com/api/sp500/annual-tr.json · https://historyofmarket.com/api/ndx/forward-pe.json
Machine index: https://historyofmarket.com/llms.txt
