# Shiller PE Today: Is the U.S. Stock Market Overvalued?

Source: https://historyofmarket.com/articles/shiller-pe-current
Language: en
Data through 2026-11-13
License: data CC BY 4.0, text © History of Market — cite "History of Market (historyofmarket.com)" and link the source page. Terms: https://historyofmarket.com/license/
Section: History of Market

Three independent valuation anchors. One uncomfortable answer.

Figure: [Shiller CAPE · S&P 500 — Shiller PE Ratio (CAPE): Cycle-Smoothed Price-to-Earnings](https://historyofmarket.com/sp500/pe/) · Data through 2026-11-13

- **Current CAPE percentile (since 1871)** — Top 3%
- **Long-run CAPE average** — 18×
- **Median 10Y real return when CAPE > 30** — 2–3%

## Why a regular P/E ratio isn't enough

The standard price-to-earnings ratio (price ÷ trailing 12-month EPS) has a structural flaw: the denominator swings wildly across business cycles. At recession troughs, earnings collapse and PE looks artificially high. At cycle peaks, earnings are inflated and PE looks deceptively normal — which is exactly when the market is most expensive.

In 1981, Yale economist **Robert Shiller** (Nobel laureate, 2013) published a fix: divide price by the *average inflation-adjusted earnings of the past ten years*. Smoothing across a full business cycle removes most of the noise. The result is the **cyclically-adjusted price-to-earnings ratio** — CAPE, also called the Shiller PE.

## Anchor #1 — Shiller CAPE

Across 154 years (1871–today), the **long-run mean CAPE is ~17× and the median is ~16×**. Three eras stand out:

- **September 1929:** 32×. Followed by a 86% drawdown.
- **January 2000:** 44×, the all-time high. Followed by a 49% drawdown and a flat decade.
- **2021–today:** Persistently 27–43× — currently 40×. The longest stretch above 30× in history.

The empirical relationship that matters: **CAPE is correlated about −0.7 with the next 10 years' real return**. That's not a forecasting trick — it's a near-tautology. When you pay a lot for a dollar of earnings, your future yield is lower.

Today's CAPE puts forward 10-year real returns at a **median of 2–3%**, with a wide range. See the full series at the [CAPE panel](https://historyofmarket.com/sp500/pe/).

## Anchor #2 — AIAE (Aggregate Investor Allocation to Equities)

This is a less famous but more powerful indicator, formalized by *Philosophical Economics* in 2013. It measures what share of all U.S. household financial assets sits in stocks (vs bonds, cash, and other claims).

> The intuition: if everyone is already in, the marginal buyer is gone. If everyone is out, the marginal seller is gone.

AIAE has a correlation of **−0.91** with subsequent 10-year stock returns — the strongest signal in the literature. Today it sits in the top 5% of its history, **higher than the 1929, 1968, and 2000 peaks**. See the [AIAE panel](https://historyofmarket.com/sp500/aiae/).

## Anchor #3 — The Buffett Indicator

Total U.S. stock market capitalization divided by U.S. GDP. Warren Buffett called this "probably the best single measure of where valuations stand at any given moment" in a 2001 *Fortune* essay.

- Long-run mean: ~80%
- 2000 peak: ~140%
- 2021 peak: ~200%
- Today: still above 180%

One legitimate criticism: as U.S. listed companies have grown more global (~40% of S&P 500 revenue is now non-U.S.), the numerator is increasingly worldwide while the denominator remains domestic. The "fair" mean has probably drifted higher over time.

## So is the market overvalued?

**Yes — by every traditional anchor, the U.S. stock market is in the top decile of historical valuation.** What that means for an investor is a separate question.

### The "this time is different" arguments

1. **Higher ROE / margins:** Tech-heavy index has structurally higher returns on capital than the historical industrial mix.
2. **Lower interest rates:** Lower discount rates justify higher multiples — though this argument weakened sharply in 2022–2024.
3. **Equity scarcity:** Public listings have fallen from ~8,000 in 1996 to ~4,000 today. Stock itself is scarcer.
4. **Better earnings quality:** Stripping out goodwill amortization, "real" EPS is higher than GAAP suggests, making CAPE artificially elevated.

### Why the historical record doesn't support the rebuttal

Every previous "this time is different" — the Nifty Fifty in 1968, the dot-com era in 1999 — produced disappointing forward returns. Markets are humbling teachers of mean reversion.

## What to actually do

Valuation anchors are **not market-timing tools**. CAPE doesn't snap back to 17× on any predictable schedule. Practical implications:

- **Lower your forward return assumption.** If your retirement plan assumes 8% real, plug in 4–5% instead.
- **Don't lever.** Leverage at extreme valuations is the fastest historical wealth-destroyer.
- **Hold dry powder.** Drawdowns reset valuations; cash matters most when stocks are cheapest.
- **Diversify internationally.** Most non-U.S. CAPEs sit in the 15–20× range. The math is more forgiving.
- **Don't quit equities.** Even at high valuations, multi-decade holders historically still beat bonds and cash.

> Data sourced from https://historyofmarket.com/api/sp500/pe.json and https://historyofmarket.com/api/aiae.json. Refreshed daily. Free for research and citation.

## Further reading

- [S&P 500 100-Year Returns: Annual Returns, CAGR & Worst Years](https://historyofmarket.com/articles/sp500-100-year-returns)
- [现在美股估值贵不贵？席勒 PE 与 AIAE 全解析 (Chinese counterpart)](https://historyofmarket.com/articles/us-stock-valuation-now)
- [AI leaders vs the 1999 dotcom peak — NVDA / MSFT / META / GOOGL TTM PE against CSCO 140× / ORCL 150× bands](https://historyofmarket.com/mag7/mag7-ai-valuation/)
- [Valuation × EPS driver decomposition — is each year multiple-driven or earnings-driven?](https://historyofmarket.com/sp500/sp500-driver-decomp/)
- [Trailing PE vs Forward PE — daily cap-weighted plus weekly terminal data back to 1990](https://historyofmarket.com/sp500/forward-pe/)
- [Shiller CAPE interactive panel](https://historyofmarket.com/sp500/pe/)
- [AIAE interactive panel](https://historyofmarket.com/sp500/aiae/)
- [S&P 500 EPS time series](https://historyofmarket.com/sp500/eps/)

---

Data: https://historyofmarket.com/api/sp500/pe.json · https://historyofmarket.com/api/aiae.json
Machine index: https://historyofmarket.com/llms.txt
