History of Market Find a chart

Will the S&P 500 Be Up in 10 Years? Every Rolling Window Since 1928

Enumerating all of history's holding windows — the base rates, the losing decades, and the one variable that predicted them.

Row = exit year · Column = entry year · Annualised price-only CAGR (dividends excluded)
198025.8
19816.6-9.7
19829.21.814.8
198311.26.716.017.3
19849.25.410.99.01.4
198511.89.214.614.513.226.3
198612.210.114.614.613.720.314.6
198710.98.912.411.910.613.98.12.0
198811.19.412.412.011.013.59.57.112.4
198912.611.214.214.113.516.113.713.419.627.3
199010.79.311.611.310.412.09.38.110.29.0-6.6
199111.910.713.012.812.313.912.011.514.014.58.626.3
199211.310.212.212.011.412.710.910.312.011.97.214.94.5
199311.010.011.811.511.012.110.49.811.210.97.212.25.87.1
199410.19.110.710.49.810.69.08.39.38.75.48.63.32.7-1.5
199511.510.612.212.011.612.611.310.912.112.19.713.310.212.214.934.1
199612.011.212.712.612.213.212.111.813.013.011.214.412.214.216.727.020.3
199713.012.313.813.713.514.513.513.414.714.913.516.615.117.420.128.325.531.0
199813.713.014.514.514.315.314.514.515.716.014.917.916.718.921.427.925.928.826.7
199913.913.414.814.814.615.614.914.916.016.415.318.017.019.021.126.224.325.623.019.5
200012.712.013.313.213.013.813.012.913.813.912.714.913.714.916.019.216.515.510.83.6-10.1
200111.310.711.811.711.412.011.210.911.611.510.312.010.711.411.914.010.99.24.3-2.3-11.6-13.0
20029.68.99.89.69.29.78.88.48.88.67.38.57.07.37.38.55.22.9-1.9-8.0-15.7-18.4-23.4
200310.29.610.510.310.010.59.79.49.99.78.59.88.58.99.110.37.76.02.3-2.0-6.7-5.6-1.626.4
200410.29.610.510.310.010.49.69.49.89.68.69.78.68.99.110.27.86.33.2-0.2-3.8-2.11.817.49.0
20059.99.310.210.09.610.09.39.09.49.28.29.38.18.48.59.57.36.03.20.2-2.7-1.12.112.46.03.0
200610.09.410.310.19.810.29.59.29.69.58.59.58.58.88.99.97.96.74.31.8-0.51.24.312.78.58.213.6
20079.89.210.09.89.59.99.29.09.39.28.29.28.28.48.59.47.56.44.22.00.01.54.210.87.26.68.53.5
20087.67.07.77.47.07.36.56.26.46.15.15.74.74.74.54.93.01.7-0.7-3.0-5.3-4.6-3.40.4-4.1-7.1-10.2-20.2-38.5
20098.17.58.28.07.67.97.26.97.16.85.96.65.65.75.66.14.33.21.2-0.9-2.7-1.9-0.43.40.0-1.7-2.8-7.7-12.923.5
20108.27.78.48.17.88.17.47.17.37.16.26.96.06.16.06.54.93.92.00.2-1.4-0.51.04.61.80.60.1-3.0-5.018.012.8
20118.07.48.17.87.57.87.16.87.06.85.96.65.75.75.76.14.63.61.90.2-1.3-0.40.94.01.60.50.1-2.4-3.811.76.20.0
20128.17.68.28.07.78.07.37.17.37.16.36.96.06.16.16.55.14.22.61.1-0.20.62.04.92.82.11.90.1-0.612.18.56.513.4
20138.78.28.88.78.48.68.17.88.07.97.17.87.07.17.17.66.35.54.12.81.72.64.07.05.24.85.03.93.915.413.513.721.229.6
20148.88.38.98.78.58.78.27.98.28.07.37.97.27.37.37.86.65.84.53.32.33.24.67.35.85.45.74.84.914.713.013.117.920.211.4
20158.58.18.68.48.28.47.97.67.87.77.07.66.87.06.97.46.25.54.23.02.13.04.26.75.24.95.14.14.212.410.610.212.912.75.2-0.7
20168.58.18.78.58.28.47.97.77.97.77.17.67.07.17.17.56.35.74.53.42.53.44.66.95.55.25.54.74.812.010.510.112.211.96.64.39.5
20178.88.48.98.88.58.88.38.18.38.17.58.17.47.57.58.06.96.35.24.23.44.25.47.76.56.36.65.96.212.811.611.413.413.49.79.114.419.4
20188.48.08.58.38.18.37.87.67.87.67.07.56.97.07.07.36.35.74.63.62.93.64.76.85.65.35.54.95.010.79.49.010.49.96.35.07.05.8-6.2
20198.98.59.08.88.68.88.48.28.48.27.78.27.67.77.78.17.16.65.64.74.04.85.98.06.96.87.06.56.812.311.211.112.512.49.89.412.113.09.928.9
20209.08.79.29.08.89.08.68.48.68.57.98.47.98.08.08.47.57.06.15.24.65.46.48.47.47.37.67.27.512.611.711.612.912.910.710.512.913.812.022.416.3
20219.49.19.69.59.39.59.08.99.19.08.59.08.58.68.79.18.27.76.96.15.56.37.49.38.48.48.78.48.813.612.912.914.314.312.612.715.216.315.523.921.526.9
20228.78.38.88.68.48.68.28.08.28.07.58.07.47.57.57.97.06.55.74.94.35.05.97.66.76.66.86.46.610.910.09.710.710.48.58.19.49.47.511.25.91.1-19.4
20239.08.69.19.08.89.08.58.48.68.58.08.47.98.08.18.47.67.16.35.65.05.76.78.47.67.57.77.47.611.710.910.811.711.69.99.811.211.410.113.710.28.30.024.2
20249.38.99.49.39.19.38.98.88.98.98.48.88.38.58.58.98.17.76.96.25.76.47.49.08.38.28.58.28.512.411.711.612.612.511.111.112.512.811.915.312.711.97.323.823.3
20259.49.19.69.59.39.59.18.99.19.08.69.08.68.78.89.18.48.07.26.66.16.87.79.38.68.68.98.68.912.712.012.012.912.811.511.512.813.212.515.413.312.89.521.319.816.4
1980198519901995200020052010201520202025
S&P 500 · Annualized Matrix — Annualized Return Matrix: Pick Any Buy and Sell Year Data through 2026-11-13
5 / 90
Negative 10-year windows
0
Negative 20-year windows
−1.7%
Worst 10-year window, annualized

The base rates, computed from every window since 1928

Using calendar-year total returns (dividends reinvested), we can enumerate every possible holding window in the record:

Holding periodWindowsNegative windowsWorst windowBest window
5 years9511 (12%)1928–1932: −12.7%/yr1995–1999: +28.6%/yr
10 years905 (6%)1929–1938: −1.7%/yr1949–1958: +20.1%/yr
20 years800 (0%)1929–1948: +2.4%/yr1980–1999: +17.8%/yr

Read that middle row carefully: out of 90 ten-year windows, only 5 ended with less money than you started (total-return basis). And the 20-year row is the famous one — zero negative windows in nearly a century of data.

Where the losing decades hide

The negative 10-year windows cluster in exactly two neighborhoods: entries at the 1929 peak (the worst: 1929–1938, −1.7% annualized) and entries at the 1999–2000 dot-com top. Both were top-percentile valuation moments. That is the honest caveat to the base rate: the odds above are unconditional, and today's CAPE of 40.0× sits at the 97th percentile of history — the neighborhood where the bad decades started.

Sequence matters less than people fear, valuation more

FAQ

Can you lose money in the S&P 500 over 10 years?

Historically yes but rarely: 5 of 90 ten-year windows since 1928 ended negative (total-return basis), all starting at the 1929 or 1999–2000 valuation peaks.

Has the S&P 500 ever lost money over 20 years?

No — every one of the 80 twenty-year windows since 1928 ended positive with dividends reinvested. The worst 20-year stretch still annualized +2.4%.

What are the odds the market is up over 5 years?

88% of the 95 five-year windows since 1928 ended positive.

Windows computed from /api/sp500/annual-tr.json (calendar-year total returns), refreshed each trading day.

Further reading